Site Search: WWW DTN

Friday, May 20, 2005

Zionism's Greatest Achievement

Twenty first century anti-Semitism is generally camouflaged in the disguise of being "dislike of Zionism" and "criticism of Israel." In fact, the goal of the "anti-Zionists" is the destruction of Israel and the shipping out of all the "Zionist" civilians and children to concentration camps. While in theory "anti-Zionism" is not exactly the same thing as "anti-Semitism," in reality it is. I have never met an anti-Zionist who was not an anti-Semite. And I include Jewish leftist anti-Zionists in this categorical statement.

Having noted this, it is also important to note one of the most important achievements of Zionism, which is that Zionism forced a major change in the natureof the expression of anti-Semitism.

For centuries, the slogans of the anti-Semites were that Jews were racially inferior, intellectually inferior, cowards, money-grubbers, killers of God, sub-humans, and so forth. B ut observe the main slogan of anti-Semites TODAY! It is that Jews are mean. They are mean to the poor Palestinians.

Ooooh, soooo mean.

What a marvelous transformation!! That the main calumny thrown at the Jews is that they are bullies, meanies. What greater accomplishment of Zionism could be imagined?

Of course, this does not mean that the anti-Semites really DO think that the Jews are mean or cruel to the Palestinians. In fact, the anti-Zionists do not give a damn about the Palestinians, and the last thing they care about is Arab human rights. This is why they have absolutely nothing to say about the treatment of Arabs in Arab countries or by the Palestinian Authority's Gestapo. When Saddam Hussein ordered Kuwaiti civilians to be forced to drink gasoline and then had his troops shoot into their bellies to make them explode to the cheers and laughs of his stormtroopers, there was not a single anti-Zionist who expressed disapproval or concern. When 200,000 Algerian civilians are murdered, the anti-Zionists have never even heard about it.

The anti-Zionists know perfectly well that Arabs are treated a thousand times better in Israel (EVEN if one were to believe all of their accusations and allegations about imaginary mistreatment of Arabs by Israel) than are Arabs in Arab countries. And, of course, they refuse to admit that the Arab treatment of non-Arab minorities in the Arab countries is even a legitimate topic of discourse.

The anti-Semites moan about the supposed Israeli mistreatment of the poor Palestinians because they think this is an effective way to delegitimize and undermine the existence of Israel. In other words, they are motivated by hatred of Jews and not by any compassion for Palestinians. They seek to see Israel destroyed, not to see Palestinians enfranchised, or - rather - their only interest in Palestinian enfranchisement is as a tool to endanger Israel's existence. Of the enormous territories of the Middle East, larger than the United States, the only place where they suddenly are concerned for the welfare and civil rights of Arabs is in Israel. The other Arabs can go to hell.

The anti-Semites have by and large lost their ability to march about and accuse the Jews of ritual murders and similar medieval libels, at least outside the Arab world's press. Such things make them laughable in the West, at least outside of Counterpunch and Antiwar.com.

No one outside the Islamic world takes the Protocols of the Elders of Zion as anything other than an embarrassment for anti-Zionists. So - instead - they have seized upon a new propaganda tactic, complaining that the Jews are Oh So Mean and Cruel and Bullies.

At long last--after two millenia of exile -- to be accused of being bullies! To leave the anti-Semites with no more effective weapon than heaping invective upon the mean Jews. For this - one must say a blessing of thanksgiving! And often.

It is Zionism's greatest achievement.


18 Comments:

Drew said...

well...I would ad that we in the west don't get to see the abuses of Arabs against Arabs...as much on TV...as we see Israeli abuse of Arabs

I think this explains why a lot of people rail against a Democracy like Israel...and yet...are silent about the abuses of say...Syria or Saudi Arabia

Fri May 20, 10:38:24 AM  
Drew said...

"To leave the anti-Semites with no more effective weapon than heaping invective upon the mean Jews. For this - one must say a blessing of thanksgiving! And often.It is Zionism's greatest achievement"

Sheer nonsense...Zionisms greatest achievement...is Israel...a land where Jews can migrate and live in relative peace and safety

Fri May 20, 10:41:11 AM  
Drew said...

"Of the enormous territories of the Middle East, larger than the United States, the only place where they suddenly are concerned for the welfare and civil rights of Arabs is in Israel."

I think many Americans feel that because they fund Israel and back her up with military might...that they are somewhat complicit...in Israeli excesses against the Palestinians

Certainly many Arabs feel that America is deeply complicit in Israel's cruel occupation of Palestine.

Fri May 20, 10:48:10 AM  
Drew said...

"That the main calumny thrown at the Jews is that they are bullies, meanies. What greater accomplishment of Zionism could be imagined?"

Perhaps...the peaceful co-existence with Israel's neighbors...complete with open borders?

I know Israel is surrounded by hostile neighbors...but still...it would be a supreme accomplishment...if Israel suddenly existed as peacefully and quietly as Switzerland...which is also surrounded -historically- by enemies

Fri May 20, 10:54:32 AM  
Stan said...

Who exactly would like to see Jews in concentration camps. Are you serious?
I think that there is a chance for Israel and Palistine to coexist in the Middle East with some changes. But Jews also live in many other parts of the world. Anti semitism is fairly rare in many of these places or at least no more common than any other bigotry based on race, religion, sex, etc.
To suggest that the option for Jews forced to leave any part of Israel would be concentration camps is inflamitory and irresponsible.

Fri May 20, 11:53:03 AM  
Stan said...

Who exactly would like to see Jews in concentration camps. Are you serious?
I think that there is a chance for Israel and Palistine to coexist in the Middle East with some changes. But Jews also live in many other parts of the world. Anti semitism is fairly rare in many of these places or at least no more common than any other bigotry based on race, religion, sex, etc.
To suggest that the option for Jews forced to leave any part of Israel would be concentration camps is inflamitory and irresponsible.
Stan

Fri May 20, 11:53:23 AM  
Stan said...

Who exactly would like to see Jews in concentration camps. Are you serious?
I think that there is a chance for Israel and Palistine to coexist in the Middle East with some changes. But Jews also live in many other parts of the world. Anti semitism is fairly rare in many of these places or at least no more common than any other bigotry based on race, religion, sex, etc.
To suggest that the option for Jews forced to leave any part of Israel would be concentration camps is inflamitory and irresponsible.
Stan

Fri May 20, 12:00:33 PM  
Stan said...

Who exactly would like to see Jews in concentration camps. Are you serious?
I think that there is a chance for Israel and Palistine to coexist in the Middle East with some changes. But Jews also live in many other parts of the world. Anti semitism is fairly rare in many of these places or at least no more common than any other bigotry based on race, religion, sex, etc.
To suggest that the option for Jews forced to leave any part of Israel would be concentration camps is inflamitory and irresponsible.
Stan

Fri May 20, 12:00:38 PM  
Stan said...

Who exactly would like to see Jews in concentration camps. Are you serious?
I think that there is a chance for Israel and Palistine to coexist in the Middle East with some changes. But Jews also live in many other parts of the world. Anti semitism is fairly rare in many of these places or at least no more common than any other bigotry based on race, religion, sex, etc.
To suggest that the option for Jews forced to leave any part of Israel would be concentration camps is inflamitory and irresponsible.
Stan

Fri May 20, 12:00:59 PM  
Stan said...

Who exactly would like to see Jews in concentration camps. Are you serious?
I think that there is a chance for Israel and Palistine to coexist in the Middle East with some changes. But Jews also live in many other parts of the world. Anti semitism is fairly rare in many of these places or at least no more common than any other bigotry based on race, religion, sex, etc.
To suggest that the option for Jews forced to leave any part of Israel would be concentration camps is inflamitory and irresponsible.
Stan

Fri May 20, 12:02:06 PM  
Stan said...

Who exactly would like to see Jews in concentration camps. Are you serious?
I think that there is a chance for Israel and Palistine to coexist in the Middle East with some changes. But Jews also live in many other parts of the world. Anti semitism is fairly rare in many of these places or at least no more common than any other bigotry based on race, religion, sex, etc.
To suggest that the option for Jews forced to leave any part of Israel would be concentration camps is inflamitory and irresponsible.
Stan

Fri May 20, 12:18:26 PM  
Stan said...

Who exactly would like to see Jews in concentration camps. Are you serious?
I think that there is a chance for Israel and Palistine to coexist in the Middle East with some changes. But Jews also live in many other parts of the world. Anti semitism is fairly rare in many of these places or at least no more common than any other bigotry based on race, religion, sex, etc.
To suggest that the option for Jews forced to leave any part of Israel would be concentration camps is inflamitory and irresponsible.
Stan

Fri May 20, 12:18:30 PM  
Stan said...

Who exactly would like to see Jews in concentration camps. Are you serious?
I think that there is a chance for Israel and Palistine to coexist in the Middle East with some changes. But Jews also live in many other parts of the world. Anti semitism is fairly rare in many of these places or at least no more common than any other bigotry based on race, religion, sex, etc.
To suggest that the option for Jews forced to leave any part of Israel would be concentration camps is inflamitory and irresponsible.
Stan

Fri May 20, 12:23:20 PM  
Drew said...

Stan...I agree with you...all 5 times that u've posted so far...please stop...and move on to another point

Fri May 20, 12:27:15 PM  
Daniel said...

I don't have much sympathy for the anti-Semitic, anti-Zionist crowd, but I don't want anything to do with your brand of macho, vulgar, triumphalist Jewish pride.

As Jews we should proud of Israel, and of its flawed but genuine democracy, and of its strength, and we should also be proud of its openness to criticism and of the fact that, because it's strong, it can withstand and incorporate criticism. When I care more about Israel's treatment of its Palestinians than I do about Arab treatment of the Palestinians, it's not because I'm a self-loathing Jew, it's because I'm a selfish Jew. It's important to me to see my tribe, as it were, act virtuously.

Fri May 20, 02:55:44 PM  
Russet Shadows said...

Amazing. The guy points out the incredibly lopsided mistreatement of Arabs by Arabs as compared to Jews mistreating Arabs and all you people can do is offer timid protests?

Drew>> Why do you think that there isn't much coverage of Arab violence in general? Because the media isn't interested in finding the truth. They're interested in guilt-mongering. However, Memri.org and others are correcting that purposeful absence.

Most Americans don't feel complicit at all. Most Americans don't give a rat's butt what the media says and are tired of hearing the constant alarm over things that aren't important or are wholly untrue. Jenin, anyone? How could the Western journalists be so snookered if they are so professional?

Stan>> The PLO's charter still calls for the total annihliation of Israel. Look at what Hamas and others want. They don't want a two-state solution. Heck, they're killing women and babies because they want total war.

Yasser had a two-state solution on a platter with the Oslo accords and he wouldn't take it. Why? Why do the Palis still exist? Because they are the wedge that Arab countries will use to destroy Israel. Search Frontpagemag for recent articles on this. There's at least one that's excellent.

Daniel>> The forces aligned against Israel are widespread and powerful. Without having at least equal media time, if not proportional media time to the crimes of the Arab governments, Israel will be forced to jump through hoops by hypocrites forever. That country and her people (or any country/people) will never be perfect, so to insist that the current media coverage is somehow fair or accurate or produces good is not true. They're putting the spotlight on Israel and ignoring say, honor killings in Jordan, or dhimmitude in Egypt, and so on. It's unadultered hypocrisy. That's what gets my goat.

Fri May 20, 09:02:11 PM  
Rightminded said...

The biggest threats to the survival of Israel are Leftists--And there are entirely to many rabid leftist in, and out of Israel.

Sat May 21, 01:56:31 AM  
dgene said...

Steve,
I know you're partially tongue in cheek.
And the self congratulation is well in order.
Yet how do we account for Israel trying to destroy itself through the blindness of a Sharon rushing to fall on his own sword ?
Well, maybe a footnote in another bible.
Thanks for the offering. You're at the top of your important game.

Sat May 21, 10:05:02 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home

Copyright 2003-2005 : DiscoverTheNetwork.org